You know how Sarah knew Nina was The Chosen One and how the Frobisher-Smythe family has a thing for trickery (mainly Sarah's Father Robert), well since Sarah knew about The Chosen One being Nina and possible her father teaching her about his ways of trickery, I believe that Sarah played a trick of her own (before her first appearance with the so called "confused" state") and she made the teachers believe that Joy was The Chosen One since they were both born on the same month and day but different hour and probably did a little fiddling with the time and just put time but not weather if it was AM or PM, probably to protect Nina so Victor and the Society couldn't put the Cup of Ankh together and when the time was right Joy can help Nina put the cup together (with that incantation) so when the cup was built she could hide and Sarah and her parents can rest in peace, also same with Rufus when Patrica told him about Nina and her having the Eye of Horus on a locket given by Sarah, the expression on his face was definitely him knowing Nina was The Real Chosen One and when he wanted to find Joy it was probably going to be similar of what he did to Patrica and Blackmail the Society plus when he was arguing with Victor about where Joy (with the society still believing she was The Chosen One) was but Victor didn't answer I believe he was doing that because he would cause serious harm to the society and the staff and students of the school grounds if Victor didn't tell him, along with what I said about him knowing The Chosen One is Nina I also believe he was pretending to believe Joy was The Chosen One (along with some of his other appearances) during the argument, Also another reason would be in the one scene in the season 1 finale he chose Nina to go with him to relieve Victor of the cup out of all the other students which to me it would mean he knew Nina was The Chosen One also when he meets Jerome he knows her full name Nina Martin but we don't see or hear Patrica tell him that and he knew that Sarah gave it to her, even with Patrica saying "a friend gave it to her" to me the look on his face after that was him being convinced that Sarah gave Nina the locket, then he went to see Sarah, along with trying to get her to tell him about the Eye of Horus with Nina and where the Cup of Ankh is hidden he also probably went there trying to comfort her and just to see her before she passes away I mean he is her Osirian, plus in the scene where we first see Rufus and Nina together when Patrica rescued him I saw the look on his face and I believe he was pretending to be surprised to see her like how he was pretending to help Patrica find Joy, oh and with him lying about the purpose with the Eye of Horus, I mean he also is a master of trickery like knowing the stuff Sarah knew and keeping the true mean with "Tipping The Scales Of Life" from the society when he went rogue, also to me his level of trickery (along with probably his family) is pretty much at the same level as Robert and Sarah (and probably the ancestors of their family) but in his way, also I believe that Rufus took more of the elixir than Victor cause we know Rufus Victor and Sarah were born on the same year 1915 but different months but Rufus looks younger than Victor so it seems to me he took more of the elixir (or took it earlier) than Victor.
Feel free to comment down below if you agree with these or what your opinion is, (P.S you know how Sarah and Rufus were being called Emily Grant and Rene Zeldman well we know Rufus went undercover as Rene Zeldman but do any of you think that he was the one that made everybody except for Victor to think Sarah's name was Emily Grant to protect her true identity I mean like I said before he is her Osirian) thank you very much.