Thread:Corbierr/@comment-5450362-20121115033814/@comment-4816103-20130328015729

I have 3 possibilities.

1. Harriet. Remember, Victor and Caroline had to have done SOMETHING to her, maybe they made her the sinner? It's very possible after all, and we haven't seen her since she arrived back at the gatehouse.

2. Piper. Now we know that the sinner looks like Patricia, but...Piper looks exactly like her! The only thing is that she's not much of a sinner...

3. Patricia.