Talk:Victor Rodenmaar Jr./@comment-1953585-20110425004143

I hate to sound like I'm defending Victor, but his plan in itself really wasn't that evil. (By which I mean, he didn't necessarily have a bad intention towards anyone.) He took Joy out of school and kept her with her father, but he never actually did anything to hurt her. As for the immortality, there was nothing inherently evil about that. Even Rufus said that Victor didn't know that using the Cup would kill the students and when Alfie keeled over, Victor was just as concerned as anyone.