Talk:Season 3/@comment-5207111-20120620041407/@comment-1639880-20120620161916

That would be incredibly stupid. "Oh, we lose the Chosen One, let's let the characters mourn. Oh, here's the new Chosen One!  Who cares how much of coincidence it is?  We still have a Chosen One to do some arbitrary task that probably wouldn't even need the Chosen One, since the Cup was assembled."

That would come off as a way to lose viewers who care about smart writing.